Cypherpunk Purity Spiral

Cypherpunk Purity Spiral is a phrase used by Charlotte Fang from January 2025 to describe the role of Milady Maker in cryptocurrency culture. Fang called Milady "an immune response" to what Fang termed web3 entryism, and "a purity spiral onto cypherpunk values". Fang uses "purity spiral", ordinarily a pejorative for groups that compete in ideological strictness, approvingly, to mean enforcing what Fang regards as the founding commitments of the crypto industry. Fang lists those commitments as five freedoms: free speech, free markets, free association, free information and free thought.
Origin
The phrase dates from the days after Vitalik Buterin adopted a Milady profile picture during leadership reforms at the Ethereum Foundation, the episode known as the Vitalik Milady Arc. The crypto commentator David Phelps criticized the choice, contrasting "crypto 2021: canceling anyone for having said the n-word" with "crypto 2025: #1 crypto figure in the world adopting pfp of community mainly known for defending the n-word". On January 23, 2025, Fang replied: "We believe in free speech, free markets and free information."[1] A few hours later Fang added:[2]
Crypto can't be stopped as a technology, but it can be undermined socially and ideologically; milady is an immune response to the web3 entryist cancer that creeped in pushing CIA agitprop—milady is a purity spiral onto cypherpunk values, feel free to tell on yourselves as plants.
Background
The argument develops Fang's 2022 essay Crypto and its Discontents: Hello Web3 Entryists, which describes calls for moderation and deplatforming in crypto as "entryism", the import of outside political norms into a field Fang regards as anarchist by nature:[3]
Web3 is a return to Web 1.0, the Wild West, only this time not by negligence of the state, but through active resistance against it… anyone calling for deplatform censorship on Web3 is an outsider entryist wielding state propaganda against the innate anarchism of crypto.
Fang returned to the theme in November 2024, writing that "you cannot call yourself a cypherpunk and also be against free speech" and describing Milady's provocations as deliberate: "a practice to break down mores and bring us back into a culture of actual anarcho liberty".[4]
The five freedoms
Fang's January 2025 reply named three freedoms: speech, markets and information. The full list of five is printed on the Milady Munitions shirt pictured above, distributed at ETHDenver in February 2025:
- Free speech
- Free markets
- Free association
- Free information
- Free thought
The shirt sets the five over a print of RSA encryption code, after the T-shirts of the 1990s that carried the RSA algorithm in protest at United States export controls on cryptography. The spiral's insignia also appears on the flier for the Milady Soiree held during the same conference. Fang repeated the list in November 2026, writing that what critics dislike about Milady "is what they fear about fundamental cyperphunk [sic] values: free speech, free markets, free association, free information, free thought."[5]
Relation to the EF Mandate
The Ethereum Foundation's March 2026 Mandate addressed how cypherpunk principles should guide the organization's work. It committed the EF to censorship resistance, open source, privacy, and security; prioritized collaborators who shared those commitments; and called for work to move beyond the Foundation as independent teams became able to sustain it.[6]
B.K. Bonkleman reads the Mandate as a test of those commitments, defending its use to select contributors and reduce dependence on the EF. The essay calls the Mandate "a public test for commitment to free speech, free association, free markets, free information, and free thought", the same five freedoms.[7]
The Mandate also reproduces the Source Seppuku License, a two-clause license by Onno Whitemoor, published on the Remilia Wiki, that pledges the author, maintainer, editor or redistributor of a piece of software to keep its source code public on pain of ritual suicide, above the wish that the Foundation "fall on its own sword" if it breaks its promise to Ethereum. After a former employee's lawsuit over her dismissal brought the license and the Mandate's Milady styling into the press in November 2026 (see Ethereum Foundation Mandate Controversy), Fang wrote that Milady was "born out of necessity as a forcing function for cypherpunk values on the entire wayward crypto industry".[5]
See also
- Cypherpunk
- Vitalik Milady Arc
- Wartime PFP
- EF Mandate
- Source Seppuku License
- Viral Public License
- Milady Soiree: Denver, February 2025
References
- ↑ @CharlotteFang77 (January 23, 2025). "We believe in free speech, free markets and free information. The only thing you believe in is the shameless, unprincipled pursuit of power—and you have none of it anymore. No one can hear you screaming from the crystals, it's time to get a new grift. Try linkedin.". X. Retrieved November 10, 2026.
- ↑ @CharlotteFang77 (January 23, 2025). "Crypto can't be stopped as a technology, but it can be undermined socially and ideologically; milady is an immune response to the web3 entryist cancer that creeped in pushing CIA agitprop—milady is a purity spiral onto cypherpunk values, feel free to tell on yourselves as plants.". X. Retrieved November 10, 2026.
- ↑ Fang, Charlotte (April 26, 2022). "Crypto and its Discontents: Hello Web3 Entryists". Mirror. Retrieved November 10, 2026.
- ↑ @CharlotteFang77 (November 30, 2024). "You cannot call yourself a cypherpunk and also be against free speech…". X. Retrieved November 10, 2026.
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 @CharlotteFang77 (November 9, 2026). "The EF is not in the business of promoting NFT's, and Milady isn't an NFT. Milady is an open-source weapon forged from fire and blood...". X. Retrieved November 10, 2026.
- ↑ Ethereum Foundation Board (March 13, 2026). The Ethereum Foundation Mandate, pp. 15–19.
- ↑ B.K. Bonkleman (May 22, 2026). "The EF Mandate: Counter-Counterrevolution". Substack.